How To Fix Watery Gravy

Download Article

When you think of gravy you think of a thick, delicious material. Nobody craves watery gravy. Unfortunately, some gravy recipes often turn out this way. Whether you're having a dinner party or you're just cooking it for yourself, there are a few ways that you can fix that liquid gravy.

1

Buy flour or cornstarch. You can buy both of these items at your local grocery store. Flour or cornstarch will help to thicken any sauce, and gravy is no exception. As long as you can avoid making lumps this option is the fastest way to thicken your gravy.
2

Mix cornstarch or flour with a little water. You should put slightly more water than cornstarch or flour. There are no exact measurements here because it all depends on the amount of gravy that you have. This isn't an exact science so you'll have to eyeball it, but you should use approximately two tablespoons of cornstarch per cup of gravy. Make sure that you make this mix in a separate bowl. Stir thoroughly until smooth.

Advertisement
3

Add the water and flour or cornstarch mixture to the gravy. Don't pour it in all at once, make sure you do this very gradually. Pour a little bit, stir, and then pour some more. Continue this process until all of your mixture is in the gravy. Now give the gravy another good stir to get rid of any cornstarch lumps that might still be in there. ^[1]
4

Remove your mixture from the heat source when the gravy thickens. When the gravy takes on a viscous look it's probably ready to go. You can also taste it with a spoon to see if it has reached the thickness you wanted. It's all about your own personal taste. Just don't let it burn. Now you are ready to serve your gravy!

Advertisement

1

Choose a fat that complements the gravy. A roux is a thickened mixture made from a fat and flour. This method is more time-consuming than the water and flour method, but the risk of lumps is minimized. Normally you should choose a fat like butter, leftover fat from the meat pan, or a suitable oil such as olive oil. The ratio is usually about half fat, half flour, although a little extra flour doesn't hurt. ^[2]
2

Melt the butter or fat in a heavy saucepan. You want the saucepan to be sturdy so that you can stir in there without the pan moving all over the place. Keep the stove on about medium heat and turn it down if you smell the butter burning. This will depend on what type of stove you have.
3

Add a similar weight of sifted flour to the melted butter or fat. Mix well, stirring constantly with a wooden spoon. Constant stirring helps to avoid making lumps. When the mixture starts to froth a little transfer it to the gravy. It should take about five minutes before the mixture froths. ^[3]
4

Stir the gravy into the mixture. Make sure you stir it well, you want the mixture to fully incorporate itself into the gravy. Otherwise you risk your gravy tasting a little strange. Keep stirring until the gravy thickens – that's how you'll know the mixture is incorporated. If the gravy still isn't thick enough to your liking you can always repeat the process with another roux.

Advertisement

1

Add 2 teaspoons of arrowroot for every tablespoon of flour or cornstarch that is called for in the gravy recipe. Arrowroot is a starch extracted from tropical fruit rhizomes. It's a fine powder and works really well as a last-minute gravy thickener. The arrowroot must be added to a little cold liquid and blended into a paste before being added to the hot gravy. ^[4]
2

Stir the arrowroot constantly while bringing the gravy to the boil. The beauty of arrowroot is that it will stay clear, which can be important for lighter colored gravy. You don't have stir really hard, just keep the arrowroot in motion while your gravy comes to a boil.
3

Remove the gravy immediately once it has reached its boiling point. Any further cooking can have the reverse effect and thin the arrowroot. As soon as you see bubbles in the gravy remove the gravy completely from the hot stove plate. Don't just turn the stove off and let the gravy sit on there – it will continue to boil! ^[5]
4

Let the gravy cool and then serve. Hopefully it has reached the consistency that you were looking for. Wait about ten to fifteen before serving your gravy so that it can cool down to an appropriate temperature. You want to be able to taste the flavor after all.

Advertisement

Add New Question

Question

Why do gravy granules get watery when cooled?

When covered, the water in the gravy evaporates and collects on the covering, then drips back into the gravy. This causes the gravy to be watery.
Question

Can I thicken it with gelatin?

Yes, or use flour.
Question

I made bacon gravy using equal parts bacon grease, flour, and milk. It browned beautifully, no lumps, but was granular in mouthfeel. Can you help?

Make sure to try and sift the flour, it will decrease the amount of "grains." Also, add the milk all at once, but slowly, so the flour doesn't clump with the milk.
Question

How do I keep leftover gravy from getting lumpy when heating it?

Amber Kopf

Community Answer

Stir it every couple of minutes if heating it up in a saucepan. If heating it up in the microwave, stir in 30 second intervals.
Question

I used canned gravy and when heated it was thick. I put into refrigerator overnight it turned to watery liquid and would not thicken again. Did I do something wrong?

What likely happened is the moisture got trapped, and when it collected on the dish, the water molecules gathered to form water droplets, and they dropped back into the gravy, making it watery. The gravy probably would not thicken again because the fat absorbed as much water as it could and the water could not evaporate.
Question

I made gravy with beef drippings last night. There is some left that I want to use it for dinner tonight, but there isn't enough. What can I add to it to make more gravy?

Use your leftover gravy as a base to make more gravy. Add commercial gravy granules and boiling water, or try adding a red wine reduction. Use water from vegetables you've boiled and a stock cube.

Ask a Question

200 characters left

Include your email address to get a message when this question is answered.

Submit

Video

Beurre manie can be added to gravy to thicken it; if made ahead and stored in the refrigerator, this can be used as a quick fix. Given that it has already enfolded the flour inside, it shouldn't cause lumps when added.
If using gravy in a meat pie, add a little gelatin to the gravy when making it, to prevent leakage of the gravy from the pie.
Try using instant mashed potato flakes as a quick fix. Use only a small amount of instant mashed potato flakes into the gravy as it cooks. Start with about a half-teaspoon at first; you can increase the amount as needed.
You can also try improving the flavor of liquid gravy to help with the taste. Add 1 tablespoon of heavy cream (double cream) or 15g/ 1/2 oz of butter for every 250ml/ 8 fl oz of gravy that you have. This could make the liquid gravy taste totally fine.
If the gravy is lumpy, it may also be quite watery. Try pushing the gravy through a sieve to break down the lumps. After you do this reheat the gravy and see if it thickens from the more evenly distributed flour. Another approach is to put cooled lumpy gravy into a blender and blend out the lumps. Don't put hot gravy into the blender, it will blow off the lid and the ingredients will explode everywhere.
A little tomato paste can help thicken gravy. You'll need to be happy with the flavor it adds though.

Thanks for submitting a tip for review!

About This Article

Article SummaryX

To thicken gravy, first mix 3-4 tablespoons (15-20 g) of flour into a little bit of water until it forms a paste. Then, just whisk the paste into the gravy a little bit at a time until the gravy is thick enough. For a gluten-free option, mix 3 tablespoons (16-24 g) of arrowroot with 3 tablespoons (45 mL) of water to form a paste, then stir the paste into the gravy. Another option is to puree some roasted vegetables, like potatoes, parsnips, or carrots, and then stir the pureed vegetables into the gravy to thicken it and add more flavor. If you want to learn how to use arrowroot to thicken your gravy, keep reading the article!

Did this summary help you?

Thanks to all authors for creating a page that has been read 639,497 times.